Highest Paid Actors Who Can’t Act

Wednesday, October 28, 2009 10:00AM - By Krystal Clark

most successful actors who can't act

Have you ever watched a movie and thought to yourself, how the hell did this person get cast? Hollywood is full of successful actors and actresses who’ve made a steady living off of their “craft,” and by craft I mean the ability to bullshit their way into films. Don’t get me wrong, there are plenty of aspiring Sean Penns out there, but for every one there are three Ashton Kutchers. For every young Meryl Streep there are five Megan Foxs and it’s been like that since the beginning of time.

Check out my list of “The Highest Paid Actors Who Can’t Act”…

David Caruso

david carusoCSI: Miami has left its predecessor in the dirt in terms of ratings and has become somewhat of a cult phenomenon thanks to David Caruso and his infamous sunglasses. Ever since I saw him in 1982’s First Blood, I should have known he was up to know good. He caused a big stink on the set of NYPD Blue and left the show after one season, only to appear in such mediocre films as Jade and Kiss of Death. Now, he’s been reborn as some kind of TV messiah put on the same level as Hugh Laurie’s Dr. House, and Kiefer Sutherland’s Jack Bauer. Sorry, but Horatio Caine has become a parody of himself and it’s mostly due to the non-intentional comedic performance given by the man behind the shades.

Estimated Annual Salary: 6 million and up

  • Actual Talent: 5/10
  • Media Exposure: 3/10
  • Overall Success: 6/10

Scarlett Johansson

    scarlett johansson

This will probably anger the general public, but Scarlett Johansson’s performances put me to sleep. She’s not a horrible actress (I’ve definitely seen worse), but she’s not as great as the media makes her out to be either. With her acting it always seems as if she’s aware of the camera. Whether its underacting (Lost in Translation) or overacting (Match Point), Ms. Johansson’s not that great. Let’s give her accolades to someone else who truly deserves them.

Estimated Annual Salary: 5 million and up

  • Actual Talent: 6/10
  • Media Exposure: 8/10
  • Overall Success: 9/10

Ashton Kutcher

ashton kutcher

This guy just doesn’t do it for me. During the peak of Kutcher’s fame during the TV series, That ’70’s Show and Punk’d I just couldn’t find his appeal. Sure, he’s a good looking guy, but Hollywood is filled with pretty faces. Ashton has managed to turn his douchebag charm into a career staple. Who can forget his roles in such cinematic classics as Dude, Where’s My Car, My Bosses Daughter, Just Married and my personal favorite What Happens in Vegas. He’s turned playing an asshole into an art form, and audiences just eat it up.

Estimated Annual Salary: No one knows! He’s doing a good job of hiding it, do you know what’s in his wallet?

  • Actual Talent: 4/10
  • Media Exposure: 9/10
  • Overall Success: 8/10

Chris ‘Ludacris’ Bridges

    chris ludacris bridges

After his appearance in the Oscar winning film Crash, I thought rapper turned actor Chris ‘Ludacris’ Bridges had a promising future ahead. I was partially right, because in the past four year’s we haven’t been able to get this guy off the screen. He’s been in everything from Max Payne to Guy Ritchie’s European flick RockNRolla. Bridges biggest problem is that he fails to connect with any of his characters. You could blindfold me and play a snippet of audio from every movie he’s ever done and I would think they were all from the same film. He’s what you call bor-ing.

Estimated Annual Salary: 10 million and up

  • Actual Talent: 3/10
  • Media Exposure: 5/10
  • Overall Success: 6/10

Common

    common

This one kind of hurts because I love Common as a music artist, but when comes to acting he is no master. Like Ludacris he has found himself in multiple big budget films and I don’t know how or why. Wanted was a crappy movie overall so his performance blended right in, but Terminator Salvation was where I really noticed his lack of “talent.” Every time he spoke, it was like nails on a chalkboard. His performance was so dull and unbelievable that it hurt my eyes. I need for him and Ludacris to go take a couple of acting classes with Will Smith and LL Cool J so they can learn how to successfully make the transition from music to film.

Estimated Annual Salary: 8 million and up

  • Actual Talent: 1/10
  • Media Exposure: 3/10
  • Overall Success: 4/10

Paul Walker

    paul walker

I will admit that Paul Walker has slightly improved his skills during the span of his career, but he is far from where he should be. Why is it that every time he’s in a movie the words, “Dude” and “Stoked” always find their way into his dialogue? After his stint as a teen heartthrob in films like She’s All That, and Varsity Blues, Walker decided to kick it up a notch by becoming a recognizable force in the action genre thanks to The Fast and the Furious. Walker epitomizes the surfer guy persona even when the role doesn’t call for it. How does he keep getting away with that?

Estimated Annual Salary: 7 million and up

  • Actual Talent: 3/10
  • Media Exposure: 4/10
  • Overall Success: 5/10

Megan Fox

    Megan Fox

Megan Fox herself has even expressed confusion when it comes to her acting. She’s only starred in a handful of recognizable movies, two of which co-starred giant robots, and after seeing her in Jennifer’s Body I’m convinced her career has been a luck of the draw. She couldn’t act her way out of a wet paper bag with a big hole in it. Like most actors in Hollywood she trades on her looks, but she doesn’t seem to understand that they won’t be around forever. One day she’ll realize that she needs more than a tube of red lipstick to get asses in the seats, but then again hasn’t Jennifer’s Body already proven that?

Estimated Annual Salary: 2 million and up

  • Actual Talent: 0.5/10
  • Media Exposure: 10/10
  • Overall Success: 6/10

Keanu Reeves

    keanu reeves

Keanu Reeves has the type of career that fellow beach boy Paul Walker could only dream of. After over 20 years in the movie business he’s built a massive career for himself off of his stoic, and unresponsive delivery. He’s pretty much played the same character in every movie he’s been in, that character being himself. In Speed he’s Keanu on a bus, in the Matrix he’s Keanu in a trench coat, in The Day the Earth Stood Still he’s Keanu in the role he was born to play. How does he do it? Damn you Keanu Reeves for half-assing it for two decades, and still laughing all the way to the bank!

Estimated Annual Salary: 15 million and up

  • Actual Talent: 5/10
  • Media Exposure: 7/10
  • Overall Success: 10/10

What actors do you think belong on this list? Who do you think should be taken off?

This website uses IntenseDebate comments, but they are not currently loaded because either your browser doesn't support JavaScript, or they didn't load fast enough.

COMMENTS

  1. Posted by Lin-z

    this is exactly what i've been thinking for a long time. just add "the rock" and late nicholas cage and you're golden.

  2. Posted by E. Cook

    Congrats, ma'am. Why aren't you a casting director yet?

  3. Posted by Woot

    People give Keanu alot of shit but I think thats just because its the trendy thing to do. I think he has a diverse on-screen persona from Falco on the Replacements to Speed. He has made his fair share of shitty movies but he isn't the same character over and over like Owen Wilson or something.

  4. Posted by Sunfox

    And your next article should be…"Writers who can't write"…..

  5. Posted by @BruinBrian

    Scarlett J?!?!? That's absurd, you're totally hating. I agree with everyone else on your list but leave my girl out of this mess of people.

  6. Posted by guest

    How about Halle Berry?

  7. Posted by Matt

    Nicholas Cage and Hayden Christiensen. Good list. It hurt me to agree with you about Johansson, but when I thought about it, I had to.

  8. Posted by BrookeJarae

    Ludacris was excellent in his reoccuring role on Law and Order: SVU, but as far as the rest of the list Scarlett is a hit or miss, tho i did luv A Love Song for Bobby Long and Vicki Cristina Barcelon, I'd keep Keanu and Ashton as well as David Caruso, i love Common too but i'm forced to agree however i would put LL Cool J on the list as well. Nicholas Cage is a must, i know i'm going to catch some hell but Halle Berry and Dennis Quaid need to be on this list as well. My fav Dennis Quaid movie was Playing By Heart, his character was hilarious and sad it's almost as if he was channeling his future career! so many more by the way, Owen Wilson, Matthew Perry, Jenifer Aniston (let's admit it folks) the list goes on

  9. Posted by Tim

    Anyone that's seen Butterfly Effect knows that Ashton can actually act.

  10. Posted by Shell

    You left off Kevin Costner. The man has vision and MAKES great films, he should just stay out from in front of the camera.

  11. Posted by Guest

    I'm glad you put this up. It also doesn't surprise me that there are people saying you've got a stick up your ass, but to them I would say they have no concept of good cinema. They can go and oogle over Transformers 2 and think that that is a high point in film. I think you're spot on. Owen Wilson should be on there too, but he is typecast, so it's not his fault entirely. Same goes for Michael Cera, but for me, my love for Arrested Development negates this most of the time. Nicholas Cage is interesting in that he's now typecast in god-awful roles, but you can see his talent in his early work like Rumblefish. Someone said Cameron Diaz too, but I think her acting in Being John Malcovich did the job adequately.

    Also Dennis Quaid, Robert Pattinson (reminds me of Keanu), Kevin Costner as was already said, Mila Jovovich, and Ice Cube.

    To sum up what I'm saying, It's that Hollywood knows it can get away with releasing crap, as some of you have so perfectly demonstrated.

  12. Posted by @LocaConPistolas

    Agree 100% with Robert Pattinson and Nicholas Cage.

  13. Posted by Ceras

    While I agree with you about Costner. He was actually very good in Dragonfly.

  14. Posted by Amandine

    Renée Zellweger

  15. Posted by Amandine

    Ho, and the main actor in Flash Forward, Joseph Fiennes. I don't know how much he's paid, but it's waaaay toooo much. My goldfish is a better actor.

  16. Posted by Will Ferrell’s the Most Overpaid Actor

    [...] at ScreenCrave we recently posted a list of the Highest Paid Actors Who Can’t Act, so imagine our surprise when we saw Forbes list of the Most Over Paid Celebrities? Some of the [...]

  17. Posted by Rebecca

    I disagree about Dennis Quaid. he made a great Doc Holliday in Kevin Costner's own Wyatt Earp. And he was good in The Rookie.
    Kevin Costner can act but he doesn't "emote" a lot… he's like a modern Gary Cooper; an Everyman.
    They aren't supposed to be supersensitive types. Manly men.
    Keanu is terribly robotic at times but redeemed himself for me in The Replacements and The Lake House. pretty darn good.
    Otherwise I like your list. Please add Cameron Diaz. I mean, awful. Just so forced are all her performances. I will never "get" the whole appeal there. I don't even think she's beautiful! Oy.
    The perfect role for her was in Vanilla Sky so she could be annoying and pathetic.

  18. Posted by Guest 02579

    Eddie Murphy, Chris Rock, everyone from SNL post Phil Hartman, DMX

  19. Posted by Guest32

    I might have thought that about Keanu before I saw the Gift, The Devil's Advocate and the Lake House. He is subtle and isn't one of those in your face actors. He reminds me a little of Clint Eastwood in his delivery. I think Keanu is one of those actors that will get his due as he gets older and finally picks the role that the critics will appreciate.

  20. Posted by Joe T

    Denzel Washington.

  21. Posted by @BruinBrian

    @ JoeT – glad to hear someone else say it!!! I've been pounding my head against the wall for years trying to figure out what people see in Denzel… He, like Dennis Quaid, is totally one note (i.e. constantly angry): being pissed at EVERYTHING does not equate to good acting.

  22. Posted by PhreshKiid.C

    David Caruso Is A Siiiick Actor WTF Is This Guy Talking About!!!!
    && Megan Fox Is Only Somewhat Pretty …Only Reason…
    I Think The Worst Actor Ever!!!!
    Was The Main Character From Superman…Whatta Loser…Batman Too
    LMFAO LMFAO LMFAO

  23. Posted by CNos

    The problem with some of the people on this list is that they are typecasted and don't really get to show off their talent off that much… except Megan Fox. There's no talent there at all.

  24. Posted by David

    The lack of Ben Stiller in this list makes me sad.

  25. Posted by Hadley

    SHIA LABOEUF!

POST YOUR COMMENTS